Background graphic
At the Lectern

Justice Evans rejects recusal request in death sentence commutation matters

November 21, 2026

On Thursday, a crime victims support group sent the Supreme Court a letter asking Justice Kelli Evans to recuse herself from two pending matters concerning the validity of Governor Newsom’s intended commutations of all California death sentences.  (Request re:  Commutation of death sentences; Friend v. Newsom; see here, here, and here.)  The next day, Justice Evans declined the request.

The three-page, single-spaced letter on behalf of Crime Victims United of California and three murder victim family members said, “Our request rests not on Justice Evans’s views on capital punishment or her appointment by Governor Newsom, but on her substantial personal involvement in the Governor’s death penalty and clemency policies now implicated in these proceedings.”  It cited Evans’s role, as the Governor’s Chief Deputy Legal Affairs Secretary, in crafting and implementing Newsom’s 2019 moratorium on state executions and in reviewing and reporting to the Governor on clemency applications.

The letter relied on Canons 3E(4)(c) and 3E(5)(c) of the Code of Judicial Ethics.  Both require mandatory appellate justice disqualification in certain situations, the former when “the circumstances are such that a reasonable person aware of the facts would doubt the justice’s ability to be impartial,” the latter when “[t]he appellate justice represented a public officer or entity and personally advised or in any way represented that officer or entity concerning the factual or legal issues in the present proceeding in which the public officer or entity now appears.”  The letter stated, “The question is not whether Justice Evans is actually biased.”

The letter does not mention that, in August 2023, Justice Evans did recuse herself from ruling on a Newsom request to allow the commutation of a life without parole sentence.  (See here.)  Evans left the Governor’s office in 2021, when she was appointed to the superior court, and she joined the Supreme Court in January 2023.

The recusal request also asked that, if Justice Evans did not disqualify herself, there be “a public explanation addressing Canons 3E(4)(c) and 3E(5)(c).”  Yesterday, the court’s Clerk/Executive Officer Jorge Navarrete wrote back simply, “I have been instructed to inform you that Justice Evans has declined to recuse herself from this matter.”

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz