A group of 31 murder victims’ family members, 28 county district attorneys, and various organizations today filed in the Supreme Court an original writ petition to void all 548 death sentence commutations Governor Newsom intends to grant. The petition — Friend v. Newsom — also asks the court to immediately stay any commutation grants.
If successful, the petition would prevent Newsom from issuing any death sentence commutations, not only those for which the Governor is constitutionally required to get Supreme Court permission.
Petitioners allege that Newsom has not followed required procedures. The California Constitution says a governor’s clemency powers are “[s]ubject to application procedures provided by statute.” Penal Code section 4802 requires commutation applications of twice-convicted felons (those whose clemencies the Supreme Court must approve) to “be made directly to the Governor, who shall transmit all papers and documents relied upon in support of and in opposition to the application to the Board of Parole Hearings.” Section 4805 requires “written notice of the intention to apply” for any sentence commutation be served on a district attorney, who then must notify a victim’s family, and allows the district attorney and the family to submit to the governor a recommendation for or against commutation.
Newsom has already told the court the statutes are inapplicable to his proposed actions. He said that he has not reviewed any clemency applications and that “[t]he Governor’s authority to grant clemency does not depend on the existence of an application.”
The writ petition also claims a “[m]ass commutation is inconsistent with the individualized process provided by statute and therefore outside the Governor’s power” and that the list Newsom submitted to the court of prisoners with multiple convictions is incomplete.