In response to the writ petition — filed in the Supreme Court yesterday — that challenges Governor Newsom’s intention to commute all current California death sentences, the court quickly called for a preliminary opposition to address whether the court “should issue an order to show cause, returnable before this court.”
“When an appellate court issues an alternative writ or order to show cause, the parties are given an opportunity for oral argument.” (Lewis v. Superior Court (1999) 19 Cal.4th 1232, 1241.) Also, the court could issue an order to show cause “[w]ithout requesting preliminary opposition or waiting for a reply.” (Rule 8.487(a)(4).)
The court likely wants to rule on the writ petition (and on the Governor’s connected request that the court allow him to commute the death sentences of prisoners with multiple felony convictions) before Newsom is out of office, which happens in 48 days.
The preliminary opposition to the writ petition is due in eight days, the day before Thanksgiving. Soon after, the court could issue an order to show cause with a highly expedited briefing schedule and a mid-December oral argument.
Calling such an argument high-profile would be an understatement.