At last week’s conference, the Supreme Court made 187 rulings. This week, there were less than half that amount, “only” 80. None of yesterday’s rulings produced a straight grant.
For those looking to read tea leaves for hints about whether the court will allow Governor Newsom to commute all pending California death sentences (here, here, and here), there were rulings that are definitely not indicators and one that might be, but most probably isn’t.
LWOP commutations recommended
See: Two more LWOP commutations approved.
These are the rulings that you shouldn’t read anything into about the death sentence commutations, as explained in the linked post.
Transfer of capital habeas petition
The court transferred to the superior court the habeas corpus writ petition in In re Pearson. The transfer was under Penal Code section 1509(g), enacted by Proposition 66 (see here), which provides, “If a [death row inmate’s] habeas corpus petition is pending on the effective date of this section, the court may transfer the petition to the court which imposed the sentence.” (See here and here.) The court affirmed Pearson’s death sentence on direct appeal in August.
This is the ruling that some might — but probably shouldn’t — see as foretelling a favorable decision for the Governor on his blanket death sentence commutations.
The Pearson habeas petition was filed in July 2016, preliminary briefing was completed in March 2017, and the court has had the authority to transfer the petition since October 2017 when Proposition 66 became effective. Why did the court wait until now, when the petitioner’s death sentence could soon be commuted, to make the transfer?
Some might see the timing as indicating the court’s reason for the transfer being that the court will soon allow commutation of the petitioner’s death sentence. However, it’s much more likely that it was a routine section 1509 transfer because the court was simply waiting until its opinion affirming the death penalty was final, which happened last month.
Dissenting vote: untimely habeas petition
The court denied review in In re Basler, but Justice Liu recorded a dissenting vote.
The Fourth District, Division One, Court of Appeal summarily denied — with a detailed order — as untimely the habeas corpus petition. The order stated that the petitioner challenged his conviction for attempted premeditated murder on grounds “he was improperly convicted under the now-invalid natural and probable consequences theory,” but that he “relie[d] on changes to the law made three or more years before th[e] petition was filed” and “fail[ed] to explain this substantial delay.”
Review denied: campus sexual assault investigation records
The court denied review in John Doe v. The Regents of the University of California. The Second District, Division One, unpublished redacted opinion (the unredacted opinion was filed under seal and the Supreme Court likewise filed under seal an unredacted petition for review) found unavailing an action to prevent the University of California Irvine from releasing to the Los Angeles Times records regarding sustained sexual assault allegations against the plaintiff — a professor who had dated another professor — following an investigation and hearing.
Division One concluded that “[i]nvestigating a formal Title IX complaint is, by law, part of the university’s public business” and that the records to be disclosed “are materials UCI gathered or created in the context of an official investigation into possible misconduct by a public educator.”