The Supreme Court announced a five-argument December calendar. The court will hear four criminal cases and one insurance coverage case.
Two of the four are on our list of the oldest unargued non-capital cases.
The insurance case will have three pro tem justices, two because of recusals and one because of the still unfilled vacancy left by Justice Jenkins’s October 2025 retirement. The vacancy will require one pro tem in each of the other four cases. (See: Why does the Supreme Court use pro tems?; cf.: Pro tem casts deciding vote in public employee retirement board case.)
The calendar shows “Opening Remarks: Special Session,” but it doesn’t say what the special session is about. It might be a memorial ceremony for Justice Joyce Kennard, who died in August.
On Wednesday, December 9, in Los Angeles, the court will hear these cases (with the issue or issues presented as summarized by court staff or, if indicated, limited by the court itself):
People v. Allen: “If a defendant has invoked his right to remain silent while being interrogated by a law enforcement officer, are incriminating statements obtained through a subsequent Perkins operation (i.e., the use of an undercover agent to question a jailed defendant) admissible as substantive proof of the defendant’s guilt at trial? (See Illinois v. Perkins (1990) 496 U.S. 292; Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436.)” When the court granted review in November 2024, it added this issue to be briefed: “What effect, if any, does the fact that the interrogating officer continued questioning after petitioner invoked his Fifth Amendment right to silence have upon the admissibility of the statements subsequently obtained during the Perkins operation?” More about the case here, here, and here. Second District, Division Five, Justice Carl Moor is the pro tem.
People v. Flowers: The court limited the issue to: “Did the Court of Appeal err by declining to remand for resentencing under the amended Penal Code section 1170, subdivision (b)? (See People v. Wiley (2025) 17 Cal.5th 1069; People v. Lynch (2024) 16 Cal.5th 730; People v. Salazar (2023) 15 Cal.5th 416; People v. Gutierrez (2014) 58 Cal.4th 1354.)” The court granted review in December 2025. More about the case here. Second District, Division Four, Justice Audra Mori is the pro tem.
People v. Henderson: When the court granted review in July 2025, it limited the issue to: “Does Penal Code section 1385.1, which bars sentencing courts from striking special circumstance findings, apply to Penal Code section 1172.6 resentencing proceedings for murder convictions occurring prior to the June 6, 1990 effective date of section 1385.1?” More about the case here. Fourth District, Division Two, Justice Douglas Miller is the pro tem.
People v. Robinson: “Is a transcript of grand jury proceedings admissible at a Penal Code section 1172.6 evidentiary hearing?” The court granted review in February 2025. More about the case here and here. Second District, Division Two, Presiding Justice Elwood Lui is the pro tem.
Montrose Chemical Corp. of California v. Superior Court: When the court granted review in December 2025, it limited the issues to: “(1) May a court conclude that contract language is not reasonably susceptible of a construction advanced by a party without first giving preliminary consideration to the extrinsic evidence proffered by the party? (2) Under what circumstances, if any, does prior judicial construction of contract language render that language not reasonably susceptible to a construction advanced by a party and preclude preliminary consideration of extrinsic evidence proffered by that party to support that construction?” The court granted review in December 2025. More about the case here. Chief Justice Guerrero and Justice Corrigan are recused. The pro tems are Fourth District, Division One, Justice William Dato; Fifth District Justice Donald Franson, Jr.; and Second District, Division Five, Presiding Justice Brian Hoffstadt.
Briefs for the cases will soon be posted here. The arguments will be live streamed. Opinions in the cases should file by March 8.