Christian Martinez, Summer Lin, Salvador Hernandez, and Richard Winton report for the Los Angeles Times, “Capping a decades-long quest for freedom, former Manson family member Leslie Van Houten was released from prison Tuesday after more than five decades behind bars for horrific murders that stunned the nation,” according to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
The release comes after a 2-1 published opinion by the Second District, Division One, Court of Appeal reversed Governor Gavin Newsom’s reversal of a parole grant. The Division One majority said that, even under “the highly deferential ‘some evidence’ standard [of review],” it found “no evidence to support the Governor’s conclusions.”
But the appellate court’s decision isn’t a done deal yet. Yes, the time to petition the Supreme Court for review has passed and, according to news accounts, Newsom’s office has said that, while he “is disappointed” by the decision, he “will not pursue further action as efforts to further appeal are unlikely to succeed.” However, the Supreme Court can still grant review on its own motion: it has until at least July 31 or, if it extends its time, until September 27 to do so. (Rule 8.512(c)(1).) The Court of Appeal won’t issue its remittitur — marking the finality and effectiveness of that court’s judgment — until the Supreme Court’s own-motion-review time has expired. (Rules 8.272(b)(1)A), 8.387(f).)
It’s not a regular occurrence, but the Supreme Court does occasionally grant review on its own motion. (See here, here, here, and here.)
[August 3 update: the Court of Appeal issued its remittitur yesterday.]
[August 8 update: Two jumps of the gun turn out to be harmless.]
Related:
2020 Supreme Court grant-and-hold of 2-1 decision upholding then-Governor Jerry Brown’s reversal of Van Houten parole grant. (See here.)
Dismissal of review because the Board of Parole Hearings had adopted new regulations governing youth offender parole hearings. (See here.)
2022 review denial of summary denial of writ petition seeking discovery regarding Governor Newsom reversal of parole grant. (See here.)