In In re Long, the Supreme Court today concludes a superior correctly granted a habeas corpus petition because it is reasonably probable that ineffective counsel led to the petitioner’s conviction for the second-degree murder of her boyfriend. The court’s unanimous opinion by Justice Goodwin Liu says the conviction must be overturned because “trial counsel’s failure to investigate the victim’s time of death was objectively unreasonable and prejudicial to Long’s defense.”
Today’s decision comes after a federal district court and the Ninth Circuit rather reluctantly denied Long habeas relief and after the superior court and the Court of Appeal summarily denied her subsequent state habeas corpus petition. It was only after the Supreme Court then issued an order to show cause, in 2015, that the superior court granted her petition.
The Fourth District, Division Two, reversed the superior court’s ruling, but the Supreme Court today reverses the appellate court’s decision, giving “great weight” to the superior court’s factual findings.