In In re Isaiah W., the Supreme Court today allows parents to delay challenging a court’s determination that no notice need be given under the Indian Child Welfare Act, which requires notification to an Indian child’s tribe of pending foster care placement or parental rights termination proceedings. The 6-1 opinion by Justice Goodwin Liu holds that a mother did not waive objecting to a no-notice finding by failing to appeal from a ruling — made after the finding — that removed her child and placed him in foster care. Instead, the mother could raise that issue on an appeal from a later order terminating her parental rights. The court so rules because the Act “imposes on the juvenile court a continuing duty to inquire whether the child is an Indian child.” The court concludes that “the federal and state statutes were clearly written to protect the integrity and stability of Indian tribes despite the potential for delay in placing a child.”
Justice Ming Chin dissents, criticizing the court’s better-later-than-never approach. He says the majority is improperly “carv[ing] out an exception for ICWA issues to the general California rule in dependency matters requiring an issue to be raised on appeal at the first opportunity.” Justice Chin laments that the child in this case “is paying a high price, and other children will continue to pay a high price, due to the majority’s permitting mother to make this delayed ICWA claim.”
The court’s opinion reverses the Second District, Division Three, Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court also disapproves a 1995 Fifth District opinion, but is in agreement with a 2009 decision by the First District, Division One, a 2002 decision by the Fourth District, Division One, and a 2001 Third District decision.