The substantial evidence rule is a formidable obstacle. The death row prisoner in In re Bell had that basic principle reinforced today. Bell beat the odds when — years after the Supreme Court had affirmed his death sentence on direct automatic appeal — the court issued an order to show cause on his habeas corpus petition and directed the appointment of a referee to evaluate the petition’s claim of jury misconduct. But the court now denies the petition in a unanimous opinion by Justice Kathryn Werdegar.
After an evidentiary hearing about the alleged misconduct — a holdout juror supposedly changed her vote to support the death sentence based on advice she had solicited from her husband — the appointed referee concluded the misconduct never occurred. The Supreme Court rejects the prisoner’s claims that the referee improperly excluded evidence and, “[g]iving great weight to the referee’s factual findings,” determines that the referee’s decision is supported by substantial evidence.