Background graphic
At the Lectern

Supreme Court again employs illegal-market-value analysis to determine credit card information thief’s eligibility for reduced sentence under Prop. 47

November 21, 2019

In People v. Liu, yet another opinion about Proposition 47, the 2014 initiative that reduces punishment and allows resentencing for certain crimes, the Supreme Court today follows up on its decision in People v. Romanowski (2017) 2 Cal.5th 903.

Proposition 47 reclassified as a misdemeanor the theft of property worth $950 or less.  In Romanowski, which is famous for its “crops or critters” reference (see here and here), the court concluded “property” includes access card account information and held the property is to be valued by identifying how much the information would sell for, which means “looking at evidence of illegal market value.”

The court’s unanimous Liu opinion, by Romanowski author Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar, goes into detail about factors to consider in determining illegal market value, and calls the calculation “a nuanced endeavor” but “nonetheless eminently feasible.”  Also, it concludes that the Court of Appeal got it wrong when it looked only at the amounts the defendant had charged to the accounts of the victims from whom she had stolen the information, and when it considered “the value of the property obtained” from the illegal charges to be the information’s minimum value.

The court vacates the judgment of the Second District, Division Eight, Court of Appeal, and tells the appellate court “to send the case back to the trial court for further factfinding as to the reasonable and fair market value of the access card information at issue.”

[Updated to add two much-needed hyphens to the title.]

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz