Background graphic
At the Lectern

Supreme Court affirms woman’s death sentence for 1988 torture-murder, and it disapproves many opinions, including one of its own

May 16, 2019

The Supreme Court today affirms the death sentence in People v. Dalton for a 1988 torture-murder committed by the defendant, her boyfriend, and another woman.  Among other things, the victim was injected with battery acid.  However, the court’s unanimous 143-page opinion by Justice Goodwin Liu vacates the death sentence for one count (conspiracy to commit murder) and vacates one special circumstance finding (lying in wait).  Other than that, the court rejects a long list of appellate arguments.

The court is negative not just about most of the defendant’s arguments, but also about a host of case law.

The court holds, “Evidence of circumstances underlying a conviction is admissible to impeach credibility if the proponent demonstrates that the evidence has ‘any tendency in reason’ to disprove credibility,” and, on that point, disapproves one of its own 2016 opinions and a number of Court of Appeal decisions — a 2011 opinion by the First District, Division One; a 2008 opinion by the Second District, Division Eight; a 1995 opinion by the Second District, Division Seven; a 1994 Fifth District opinion; a 1998 opinion by the First District, Division Two; and a 1988 opinion by the Fourth District, Division Three.

In finding no merit in a claim that the conspiracy to commit murder charge was barred by the statute of limitations, the court disapproves 1998 and 2012 opinions by the Second District, Division Seven.

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz