Background graphic
At the Lectern

Summary of November 30, 2016 conference report for civil cases

December 2, 2016

The following is our summary of the Supreme Court’s actions on petitions for review in civil cases from the Court’s conference on Wednesday, November 30, 2016. The summary includes those civil cases in which (1) review has been granted, (2) review has been denied but one or more justices has voted for review, or (3) the Court has ordered depublished an opinion of the Court of Appeal.

Review Granted

LTL Commercial v. Hammer IRP LTL Associates, S237689 – Review Granted and Held – November 30, 2016

In an unpublished opinion, the Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Two, affirmed summary judgment for a defendant developer in a negligence action brought by a property owner.  The Court of Appeal agreed that the claim was barred by the statute of limitations and two contractual releases.  The developer moved for more than $200,000 in attorneys’ fees, and the trial court denied that request.  Affirming the denial of the attorneys’ fee motion, the Court of Appeal ruled the developer’s successful invocation of an earlier settlement agreement and release as a defense to the plaintiff’s negligence claim did entitle the defendant to attorneys’ fees.  The court reasoned that, under the plain language of the settlement agreement’s attorneys’ fee provision, the defendant did not “initiate, commence or prosecute” any action or proceeding.

The Supreme Court granted review and ordered that further action be deferred pending the Court’s decision in Mountain Air Enterprises, LLC v. Sundowner Towers, LLC (S223536), which presents the following questions:  (1) Does the assertion of an agreement as an affirmative defense implicate the attorney fee provision in that agreement? (2) Does the term “action” or “proceeding” in Civil Code section 1717 and in attorney fee provisions encompass the assertion of an affirmative defense?

Review Denied (with dissenting justices)

None.

Depublished

None.

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz