Background graphic
At the Lectern

Summary of August 12, 2015 conference report for civil cases

August 14, 2015

The following is our summary of the Supreme Court’s actions on petitions for review in civil cases from the Court’s conference on Wednesday, August 12, 2015. The summary includes those civil cases in which (1) review has been granted, (2) review has been denied but one or more justices has voted for review, or (3) the Court has ordered depublished an opinion of the Court of Appeal. This week, the Court has granted the Ninth Circuit’s request to answer a certified question of state law.

Review Granted

Gradillas v. Lincoln General Insurance Company, S227632—Request for Certification Granted—August 12, 2015

At the request of the Ninth Circuit, the Supreme Court agreed to decide a question of California law. The Supreme Court rephrased the issue as follows: “For purposes of coverage under an automobile insurance policy, what is the proper test for determining whether an injury arises out of the ‘use’ of a vehicle?”

A passenger who was sexually assaulted by the driver on a party bus obtained a stipulated judgment against the bus owner, who assigned to the passenger his rights against his insurance carrier. The passenger sued the insurer, alleging that the insurer breached its duty to defend and indemnify its insured. In a published decision, Gradillas v. Lincoln Gen. Ins. Co., __ F.3d __, No. 13-15638, 2015 WL 4068840 (9th Cir. July 6, 2015), a Ninth Circuit panel asked the California Supreme Court to answer this question of state law: “When determining whether an injury arises out of the ‘use’ of a vehicle for purposes of determining coverage under an automobile insurance policy and an insurance company’s duty to defend, is the appropriate test whether the vehicle was a ‘predominating cause/substantial factor’ or whether there was a ‘minimal causal connection’ between the vehicle and the injury?”

Hamilton v. Yates, S226450—Review Granted—August 12, 2015

The Court of Appeal affirmed the dismissal of an action due to the plaintiff/appellant’s failure to appear for trial. This case presents the following issues: (1) Did the trial court err in concluding that there was no means of affording the indigent prisoner plaintiff in this case access to the courts to pursue his civil action? (2) Did the trial court err by dismissing the action for the plaintiff’s failure to appear in such circumstances?

Petitioner, a California inmate serving a life term at San Quentin, filed a civil lawsuit against several defendants alleging excessive force and violation of his rights while incarcerated at Pleasant Valley State Prison. Code of Civil Procedure section 581, subdivision (b)(5), permits a court to dismiss an action when a party fails to appear for trial and the other party requests dismissal. In an unpublished opinion, Hamilton v. Yates, Case No. F069608,the Fifth District Court of Appeal held the trial court did not abuse its discretion in dismissing the appellant’s case, where the appellant failed to personally appear for trial due to his imprisonment and also failed to provide the court with a reasonable option for conducting the jury trial of his action.

City of Petaluma v. Superior Court (Waters), S227539—Review Granted and Transferred—August 12, 2015

In this writ proceeding initiated by a municipality, the Supreme Court granted review and transferred this matter to the Court of Appeal, First District, Division Three, with directions to vacate its order denying mandate and to issue an order directing the trial court to show cause why relief sought should not be granted. The Supreme Court also dissolved its temporary stay of the trial court’s Memorandum of Decision on Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Further Responses to Discovery without prejudice to the petitioner requesting a stay in the Court of Appeal or the Superior Court.

Review Denied (with dissenting justices)

None.

Depublished

None.

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz