Background graphic
At the Lectern

Prosecutor’s improper dismissal of grand juror doesn’t necessarily taint indictment

December 24, 2018

In Avitia v. Superior Court, the Supreme Court today holds that although a prosecutor has no authority to dismiss a grand juror, even a biased one — that’s the grand jury foreperson’s job — such an improper dismissal does not automatically require setting aside an ensuing indictment. Rather, the court’s opinion by Justice Goodwin Liu says the defendant must show the wrongful dismissal “reasonably might have had an adverse effect on the impartiality or independence of the jury.” The court concludes that the required showing wasn’t made in this case because the prosecutor acted outside the presence of the grand jury and because the removed grand juror, having admitted he could not be impartial, would probably have been bounced by the foreperson anyway.

Justice Liu’s opinion is for six members of the court. Justice Ming Chin concurs separately. (Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye signs both the majority and the concurring opinions.) Calling the prosecutor’s action “a technical error,” Justice Chin laments that the dismissal of the grand juror “is not as pernicious as the majority opinion makes it appear” because that juror “was biased against defendant.”

The court affirms the Third District Court of Appeal.

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz