Answering a question from the Ninth Circuit, the Supreme Court in Ruelas v. County of Alameda today holds that “nonconvicted incarcerated individuals working in a county jail for a private company [do not] have a claim for minimum wage and overtime under California law.” The question, the court says, “proceeds from the assumption that nonconvicted incarcerated individuals participating in the public-private program do so voluntarily.”
The court’s unanimous opinion by Justice Kelli Evans “examine[s] the interplay among the Penal Code, the Labor Code, and the constitutional provisions governing public-private contracts for inmate labor” and finds dispositive that, under Penal Code section 4019.3, “Counties . . . may — but are not required to — credit inmates, including pretrial detainees, up to two dollars per eight-hour shift, notwithstanding the legal minimum wage, which is much higher.” The court rejects the argument that section 4019.3 doesn’t apply to public-private work programs, regardless of whether “there may be sound policy reasons for and against such a distinction.”
Included in its discussion of the broader policy question that it leaves to the Legislature, the court notes, “The California Reparations Task Force (Gov. Code, former § 8301 et seq.) has recommended that ‘the Legislature provide payment of the fair market value of the labor provided by incarcerated persons, whether they are in jail or prison.’ ” (Link added.)
[July 26 update: The Ninth Circuit today held in a published opinion that the Supreme Court’s “response makes clear that Plaintiffs’ minimum wage and overtime claims fail and the district court should have granted Defendants’ motion to dismiss both of those claims.”]