Background graphic
California Court of Appeal

Court of Appeal again rejects punitive damages claim due to lack of financial condition evidence (Young v. Sarriedine)

June 14, 2022

Just two days ago we noted that California appellate courts often reverse punitive damages awards because the plaintiff failed to introduce meaningful evidence of the defendant’s financial condition.  Here’s a case in which the trial court vacated a jury’s punitive damages award on the same ground, and the Court of Appeal affirmed.

In this defamation case, the jury ruled for the plaintiffs and awarded $44,500 in compensatory damages and $55,000 in punitive damages.  The trial court vacated the punitive damages award because the plaintiff failed to present evidence of the defendants’ financial condition.

The plaintiffs appealed, arguing their evidence of financial condition was sufficient.  The Court of Appeal (Fourth District, Division Three) disagreed.  It noted that plaintiffs presented evidence that one defendant was a Mercedes-Benz dealership, and the other defendant was a salesman who sold 9,000 vehicles a year.  But the plaintiffs presented no evidence of the defendants’ expenses or liabilities: ” ‘we may not infer sufficient wealth to pay a punitive damages award from a narrow set of data points, such as ownership of valuable assets or a substantial annual income.’ “

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz