For the second week in a row, the Supreme Court at its Wednesday conference decided not to hear any new cases. There weren’t even any grant-and-holds this time. However, the court wasn’t unanimous in not wanting to make any straight-grant orders. The conference actions of note included:
- The court denied review in S.Y. v. Superior Court, but Justice Leondra Kruger recorded a vote to grant. [Disclosure: Horvitz & Levy filed the petition for review as pro bono counsel.] The court had previously granted review in the writ proceeding, sending the case back to the Fourth District, Division One, Court of Appeal after that court had summarily denied the writ petition in the case. On remand, the appellate court in a published opinion upheld a superior court order awarding joint custody of a child to a mother and father, despite a rebuttable statutory presumption that the father’s domestic violence against the mother made awarding him joint custody “detrimental to the best interests of the child” and despite the trial court’s reliance — which was improper, but harmless, the appellate court concluded — on the father’s greater fluency in English than the mother. The Fourth District also expressly disagreed with a 2018 decision of the Second District, Division Seven, regarding how detailed the trial court’s statement of reasons needs to be.
- There was one criminal case grant-and-transfer and two habeas corpus petition transfers with orders to show cause, one to the superior court and one to the Court of Appeal.