Background graphic
At the Lectern

Non-employee physician at public hospital can be charged with criminal self-dealing

June 26, 2017

In People v. Superior Court (Sahlolbei), the Supreme Court today allows the Riverside County DA to proceed with the prosecution of a surgeon for allegedly pressuring a public hospital to hire another physician whose contract would benefit the surgeon.  Government Code section 1090 prohibits certain public “officers or employees” from being “financially interested in any contract made by them in their official capacity.”  The surgeon — and the Court of Appeal — said section 1090 doesn’t apply to him because he practices at the hospital as an independent contractor, not an employee.  The court’s unanimous opinion by Justice Goodwin Liu holds the distinction doesn’t matter in this case, concluding that, although not “all independent contractors are covered by section 1090,” the statute does apply “to independent contractors who can be said to have been entrusted with ‘”transact[ing] on behalf of the Government.”‘”

More specifically, the court finds no problem in exposing physicians at public hospitals to section 1090 liability.  The justices say they “are not convinced that the practice of medicine cannot bear the weight of conflicts of interest statutes.”

The court reverses a 2-1 decision from the Fourth District, Division Two, Court of Appeal.  It also disapproves a 2013 opinion by the Second District, Division One.

Sahlolbei was argued on the April calendar.  There are still five undecided cases from that calendar, and only two more regular filing days within the 90-day deadline to issue opinions in those cases.

Put Our Proven Appellate Expertise to Work for You.

For over 60 years, we've preserved judgments, reversed errors, and reduced awards in some of California’s most high-profile appellate cases.

Explore our practices Explore Careers
Horvitz