Kansas and California have somewhat similar methods of selecting and electing their supreme court justices, methods that significantly reduce the influence of partisan politics. However, pending legislation would, if adopted, move the two states in dramatically opposite directions.
In California, a Supreme Court justice is nominated or appointed by the governor, is confirmed by the three-member Commission on Judicial Appointments, and the sitting justice then at some point stands for election at which there can be no other candidates; voters decide only “yes” or “no” whether the justice should remain on the court. (See here.) In Kansas, the governor appoints one of three people whose names are submitted by a “nonpartisan nominating commission,” and that justice is later subjected to a “yes” or “no” retention election. (Kansas constitution, article 3, section 5.) The justices in both states are not identified on the ballot by party designation.
As we wrote about last month, a proposed amendment to California’s constitution would eliminate most “yes” or “no” elections. Those elections would be held only if enough voters petition for a justice’s name to appear on the ballot. A proposed amendment to Kansas’s constitution, on the other hand, would abolish the current system and provide for contested elections of the justices.
We learned of the Kansas proposal from Rick Hasen’s Election Law Blog.
Related:
The specter of more frequent “100-year floods”
“Thirty Years After a Hundred Year Flood: Judicial Elections and the Administration of Justice”