In People v. Carney, the Supreme Court today holds that defendants who participated in a gang gun fight can be guilty of first degree murder even though they definitely didn’t fire the shot that killed the victim. The one who did fire that shot was acquitted of murder and convicted only of voluntary manslaughter.
The court’s unanimous opinion by Justice Martin Jenkins is a follow-up to an earlier decision — People v. Sanchez (2001) 26 Cal.4th 834 — upholding a murder conviction where it was unclear whether the defendant had fired the fatal shot. The court concludes that “the conduct of a participant in a gun battle who did not fire the fatal shot may contribute substantially and concurrently to — and be a proximate cause of — the victim’s death.” Murder liability can follow from “a defendant’s ‘life-threatening deadly acts’ in a gun battle.”
When the court granted review, it limited the issues; the second of two was: “What impact, if any, do People v Chiu (2014) 59 Cal.4th 155 and Senate Bill No. 1437 (Stats. 2018, ch. 1015, § 1, subd. (f)) have on the rule of Sanchez?” (Link added.) It later asked for supplemental briefing to address “the significance, if any, of Senate Bill No. 775 (Stats. 2021, ch. 551) to the issues presented in this case.” (Link added.) Chiu held an aider and abettor can’t be convicted of first degree premeditated murder under the natural and probable consequences doctrine, SB 1437 eliminated murder liability under that doctrine, and SB 775 refined SB 1437. The court today says Chiu and SB 1437 “have no direct effect” on Sanchez, rejecting defendants’ “effort to bring the definition of proximate cause, which deals with the actus reus of a crime [citation], within the ambit of Senate Bill No. 1437 and Chiu’s discussion of the natural and probable consequences doctrine, which both concern the mens rea of a crime.” The opinion doesn’t specifically mention SB 775.
The court affirms the Third District Court of Appeal’s unpublished opinion.