On Monday morning, the Supreme Court will file its opinions in Walker v. Superior Court and McHugh v. Protective Life Insurance. (Briefs here; oral argument videos here and here.)
In Walker, the court is expected to decide whether the superior court violated the rule of People v. Sanchez (2016) 63 Cal.4th 665 (see here) — that an expert cannot relate case-specific hearsay unless the facts are independently proved or covered by a hearsay exception — by relying on case-specific hearsay contained in psychological evaluations in finding probable cause to commit petitioner under the Sexually Violent Predator Act. The court granted review in September 2020.
McHugh raises the issues: (1) Were the provisions of Insurance Code sections 10113.71 and 10113.72 intended by the Legislature to apply, in whole or in part, to life insurance policies in force as of January 1, 2013, regardless of the original date of issuance of those policies? (2) Did the lower courts in this case properly rely upon private opinions of Department of Insurance staff counsel? (See Ins. Code, § 12921.9; Gov. Code, § 11340.5; Heckart v. A-J Self Storage, Inc. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 749 [see here].) Review was granted in January 2020.
These are the last undecided cases argued on the June calendar. One more opinion — from the early-May calendar and delayed by post-argument briefing — should file by September 13 and then there could be a two-month gap until the next decision. This is a function of the summer pipeline emptying (because of the 90-day rule) and no new cases heard during argument-less July and August.
[Update: Here’s a caveat on the coming opinion drought — the court might issue an opinion in September or October on the motion to further extend redistricting deadlines.]
The Walker and McHugh opinions can be viewed Monday starting at 10:00 a.m.