In Sweetwater Union School District v. Gilbane Building Company, the Supreme Court today holds plaintiffs can use hearsay declarations and transcripts of testimony under oath — in the case before it, forms changing criminal pleas and transcripts of grand jury testimony — to defeat a motion to strike under the anti-SLAPP statute. Noting how early in a lawsuit the motions are normally made, the court’s unanimous opinion by Justice Carol Corrigan states that “[t]o strike a complaint for failure to meet evidentiary obstacles that may be overcome at trial would not serve the SLAPP Act’s protective purposes.” Nonetheless, the court says that, even though the declarations and transcripts themselves need not necessarily be admissible at a trial, it must be “reasonably possible the evidence set out” in them will be admissible.
The court affirms the Fourth District, Division One, Court of Appeal. It also disapproves 1998 opinions by the First District, Division Two and the Second District, Division Two. The court’s desire to disapprove those two opinions probably explains why the court opted to decide Sweetwater even though the case was mooted by a settlement two years ago.