The Supreme Court’s February calendar will have eight cases, five of them criminal matters, and four of those five being automatic direct death penalty appeals.
On February 5 and 6, in Sacramento, the court will hear the following cases (with the issue presented as summarized by court staff or stated by the court itself):
Black Sky Capital, LLC v. Cobb: Does Code of Civil Procedure section 580d permit a creditor that holds both a senior lien and a junior lien on the same parcel of real property arising from separate loans to seek a money judgment on the junior lien after the creditor foreclosed on the senior lien and purchased the property at a nonjudicial foreclosure sale? [Disclosure: Horvitz & Levy filed an amicus curiae brief in the case.] The court granted review in September 2017.
People v. Bell: This is an automatic direct appeal from a June 1999 judgment of death. The court’s website does not list issues for such cases. Defense counsel was appointed in January 2004, new counsel was appointed in 2009, and briefing was completed in March 2015.
People v. Dalton: This is an automatic direct appeal from a May 1995 judgment of death. The court’s website does not list issues for such cases. Defense counsel was appointed in December 1999 and briefing was completed in June 2009.
[February 1 update: Two days ago, and just six days before oral argument, the court asked for supplemental briefing in Dalton regarding whether imposition of a death sentence on one count against the defendant was unauthorized because conspiracy to commit murder does not render a defendant death eligible. The court’s order referenced People v. Vieira (2005) 35 Cal.4th 264, 294 and People v. Lawley (2002) 27 Cal.4th 102, 171-172. The briefs are due after the argument.]
People v. Lara: Originally a grant-and-hold case, with action deferred pending the decision in People v. Page, the court un-held the matter in March 2018 and ordered briefing on the issue whether Penal Code section 490.2, added by Proposition 47, effective November 5, 2014, applies directly (i.e., without a petition under Penal Code section 1170.18) in trial and sentencing proceedings held after Proposition 47’s effective date, where the charged offense was allegedly committed before Proposition 47’s effective date.
People v. Sanchez: This is an automatic direct appeal from a March 2000 judgment of death. The court’s website does not list issues for such cases. Counsel was appointed in December 2005 and briefing was completed in January 2018. Argument in the case was originally scheduled for the January calendar, but was continued.
FilmOn.com v. DoubleVerify, Inc.: This is an anti-SLAPP case. The issue is, in determining whether challenged activity furthers the exercise of constitutional free speech rights on a matter of public interest within the meaning of Civil Code section 425.16, should a court take into consideration the commercial nature of that speech, including the identity of the speaker, the identity of the audience and the intended purpose of the speech? The court granted review in November 2017.
People v. Caro: This is an automatic direct appeal from an April 2002 judgment of death. The court’s website does not list issues for such cases. Counsel was appointed in July 2006 and briefing was completed in May 2015.
Melendez v. San Francisco Baseball Associates LLC: This case concerns whether arbitration is required. The issue is, does plaintiffs’ statutory wage claim under Labor Code section 201 require the interpretation of a collective bargaining agreement, and is it therefore preempted by section 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act? The court granted review in January 2018.